There are many different types of blog, even in Hong Kong.

The first one I read was Hemlock’s diary, which is unusual (but not unique) in that it is both anonymous and partially fictional. The way it is written leaves the reader deliberately unsure how much of any particular story might be true, and one assumes that the more outrageous tales are not (quite) true.

At the other extreme, we have blogs such as See Lai and UK Joe where the authors tell us clearly who they are, with photographs and any other details we may desire. Naturally. these people exercise a certain amount of caution in writing about their personal lives.

Then we have the people like Phil (Flying Chair) and Simon – and myself – who don’t put their full names on their sites, but are somewhat circumspect in what they write about themselves, friends and families.

However, some of the most high profiles bloggers in Hong Kong are very careful to hide their real identities and then write very frankly about their lives, safe (??) in the knowledge that they can remain anonymous. Of course, we have no way of verifying that what we read is true (or complete), but the assumption is that having chosen to "confess" in this way, they don’t hold anything back. The problem is that posting information on the Internet is about as public as you can get, and I sometimes feel a bit uncomfortable reading this stuff (especially after a while, when you feel that you have got to know the person who is writing it).

In the last few days, both Shaky and Conrad (Gweilo Diaries) have written things that made me wonder. Both, of course, involve women. Shaky has been recounting his ‘courtship’ of a young lady and we have Conrad being very indignant that an ex-girlfriend is asking for his help because she is pregnant.

I certainly don’t wish to pass judgement on either of these matters. They don’t concern me personally, and I wouldn’t be offering unsolicited advice or passing judgement (even if I knew all the facts, which I don’t). My only point is that these people have chosen to write about these matters on a blog where comments are solicited, and needless to say some people have jumped in and had their say.

It takes all sorts to make a world, or something like that, but I think I’ll stick to writing about transport policy, politics, the weather, intelligent crows and so forth.
[all links deleted – only Hemlock’s site is still available]

Posted in

6 responses to “Way too much information”

  1. Ron avatar

    Chris,
    When I started blogging, I made a conscious decision to represent exactly who I am.
    I am fully aware about the consequences, but at my age, I won’t be looking for a job, I can hardly be a movie star, I have no interest in being a politician, so the risks were not as great as say someone younger to me.
    I have received suggestions about anonymous blogging and if I went for that, it might open a totally different side of me [not related to personal life, but rather political and economical views].
    However, I think they would be too strong and radical and I hardly believe there is anything anonymous on the Internet.
    No matter, how hard one conceals identities or does anonymous blogging via proxy or fake identities, etc., you see the connections one uses to get on the Internet can never be anonymous.
    Folks at http://www.anonymizer.com offer anonymous connections. But those were good during the telephone modem days. In the world of broadband and now broadband TV, most end up with fixed or jumping IP’s.
    I know more than a whole crowd who could trace, ping, or whatever those smartypants do, to find out who is who.
    After all these considerations, I decided to go ahead and blog under real name, identity, pictures, etc.
    And no I am not talking about Big Brother yet.
    Cheers!

    Like

  2. the shaky kaiser avatar

    information

    Ordinary Gweilo has a post on what he thinks about HK blogs. He’s not always comfortable with what some people write, but doesn’t want to pass judgement: However, some of the most high profiles bloggers in Hong Kong are very…

    Like

  3. Chris avatar

    Yes, well, that was rather what concerned me. Good luck to Conrad, Shaky and others who choose to write what they do, but I certainly wouldn’t want to do it!

    Like

  4. ukjoe avatar
    ukjoe

    Hehe..I don’t think I am all that extreme, in fact, I don’t put my full name there, and in fact Phil does have his full there on the site.
    I don’t allow search engine indexing my site. So if you type ukjoe from google, you will probably just find the gallery there, because of the URL, which I kinda have no control over. Of course, if someone has to look up ukjoe on any search engine, they can still find the comments from others sites I have posted to, and then the url of my site has been attached to it, which was my mistake, I suppose.
    I guess you are right, I exercise caution about what I write online. I try to write mostly about my own life and MY relationship with others. It may be egotistical and it might leave me open to some valid criticisms about authorship and identity and subjectivity, but I try to keep the particulars of others’ life to a minimum online. I try not to talk too much of my job too.

    Like

  5. Chris avatar

    I wasn’t aware that you could “hide” a site from Google, but I am not very good on all the technical stuff (as you would guess from the fact that I use Typepad). When Phil starts talking about SQL and Shaky worries about Movable Type add-ins, I switch off!
    Obviously the Google thing is one concern if you want to maintain a degree of anonymity. In some ways the ideal situation might be that anyone who reads the blog should know who you are, but that everyone who knows you shouldn’t be able to find the blog unless you want them to.

    Like

  6. ukjoe avatar
    ukjoe

    I totally agree with you about not everyone knows you should be able to find your blog unless you want them to. I have had a coworker who had too much interests about me and went to google and looked up ukjoe and found my site and even STALKED me. I screwed myself by using a personal email address one time and he saw my login name, ukjoe. Crazy!!
    Yes, you can request to have your indexed page or entire site removed from google, and you can also save a robot text to disallow any search engine from indexing your site.
    Check that out:
    http://www.google.com/webmasters/3.html#removed

    Like

Leave a comment