I am no longer a regular reader of the SCMP, but I do sometimes buy it on Saturday. I’m not sure why, though. Yesterday, the front page of the ‘City’ section (Hong Kong news that is too dull to go in the main paper, plus features and sport) looked like this:

The top story was Concern mounting over pre-court tipples (shockingly, lawyers are sometimes to be found drinking at lunchtime), then there’s Man’s hand chopped off in attack at Mongkok restaurant (chicken feet are one thing, but I draw the line at someone else’s body parts in my dim sum), and Authority restricts steroid use in treating Sars (maybe it’s not such a good idea to give people high doses of drugs that might cause serious harm). Plus a court report about a 16 year-old who stabbed his pregnant girlfriend with a fruit knife, with the wonderfully droll line: “Turning to see her lover holding the bloodstained knife, she asked him why he had stabbed her.” As I think we all would if we found ourselves in similar circumstances. An hour or so later she went to hospital for treatment, which gives you an idea how serious it was.

There was also a picture from the ‘Miss Hong Kong’ pageant, which means that thankfully I have managed to avoid watching it for another year. I did catch a few seconds of one of the irritating comedians being rude and patronising to one of the contestants, but that was all. How is this possibly a news story?

The dullest and funniest story is reserved for page three. It seems that someone has stolen a tree (worth HK200) from park in Kowloon City. Well, the story says that the tree is worth $200, but that property developers pay tens of thousands of dollars for good specimens, so I’m not sure what to believe. Surely it’s worth whatever someone is willing to pay? I have an idea – perhaps the LCSD should start selling these trees if they only cost a couple of hundred dollars and are worth so much to property developers.

This is what makes the SCMP such an enigma. Is it a serious paper that prints important news and analysis, or is the equivalent of the Chingford Weekly Examiner running stories about lost dogs and stolen property? Well, given the relative priorities given to these stories, I think I’ll go for the latter.

Posted in

7 responses to “Read all about it – tree stolen”

  1. Simon World avatar

    Asia by Blog

    Asia is an interesting place… Hong Kong, Taiwan and China Tom follows-up on the fate of Chinese dissident law professor Yuan Hongbing. He also has a further follow-up on Li Dan, a well-known Chinese AIDS activist, and reports on Roger Moore’s visit t…

    Like

  2. Spirit Fingers avatar

    I wonder if anyone subscribes to the online version. I just buy it on Sunday for the tv guide.

    Like

  3. Chris avatar

    Yes, I buy it on Sunday as well.
    I have, ahem, access to the online version.

    Like

  4. Simon World avatar

    Asia by Blog – Month in review

    Thank you to everyone for the good wishes. Everyone is doing well. Now to keep you going…as part of the Winds of Change team I provide a monthly briefing on Asian goings-on, particularly China and SE Asia. I thought this would give me a good opportun…

    Like

  5. Simon World avatar

    Asia by Blog – Month in review

    Thank you to everyone for the good wishes. Everyone is doing well. Now to keep you going…as part of the Winds of Change team I provide a monthly briefing on Asian goings-on, particularly China and SE Asia. I thought this would give me a good opportun…

    Like

  6. Winds of Change.NET avatar

    Simon’s E. Asia Overview: Aug 25/04

    It’s time to have a look at East Asia and what’s been making the news in Asian blogs over the past month. We cover China (in depth), as well as Taiwan, Hong Kong, Korea, Japan, and Southeast Asia (Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore et. al).

    Like

  7. Winds of Change.NET avatar

    Simon’s E. Asia Overview: Aug 25/04

    It’s time to have a look at East Asia and what’s been making the news in Asian blogs over the past month. We cover China (in depth), as well as Taiwan, Hong Kong, Korea, Japan, and Southeast Asia (Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore et. al).

    Like

Leave a reply to Simon World Cancel reply