• Today’s SCMP on how the Hong Kong media reports suicides:

    Reckless media reports encourage suicides, say experts at HKU centre

    Experts from HKU centre say irresponsible reporting may trigger epidemic of people taking their lives and put pressure on families

    Jennifer Ngo | South China Morning Post | Sunday, 08 September, 2013

    Irresponsible media reporting of suicides encourages copycats and may even trigger an epidemic, warn experts from the University of Hong Kong’s Centre for Suicide Research and Prevention.  It also caused additional hurt and put pressure on victims’ families, a seminar heard yesterday. [..]

    The centre yesterday released a guideline for media, developed with the Hong Kong Press Council, on how to report suicide cases ethically and avoid becoming a catalyst for copycat suicides.

    Apple Daily is probably the worst offender, but the South China Morning Post (which presumably likes to think of itself as a respectable newspaper) is also guilty of reporting suicides in an irresponsible way, with information that can only have come from the police and speculation about why the individual chose to take their own life.  

    Surprisingly, The Standard seems to be more responsible than the SCMP, managing at least to keep its reports more factual. 

    I have been told that the reporting of suicides has improved compared to a few years ago, but it still falls a long way short of the guidelines that have been adopted by most British newspapers.  The story does not state whether any newspaper has committed to follow these new guidelines. 

    Guidelines for Reporting Suicides

    Reporting Approach

    1. Editing

    • A suicide incident should not be placed on the front page of a newspaper or a media website unless it is in the public interest or is of grave public concern.
    • Avoid using a large headline when reporting a suicide incident.
    • Media websites should avoid cross-references with other suicide incidents reported on the website. Cross-references should instead be made to websites providing mental health services.
    • Avoid reporting past suicide incidents repeatedly.
    • Extra care should be taken when handling suicide incidents that involve notable persons, as their behavior is likely to be replicated because many view them as heroes or role models.

    2. News Content

    • Avoid a detailed description of the suicide method or process.
    • Avoid using an emotional or glorifying tone to describe the suicidal behavior.
    • Avoid describing suicide as a solution.
    • Avoid presuming the reason for the suicidal behavior or simplifying the reason behind the suicide.

    3. Use of Photographs

    • Avoid printing sanguinary, violent, revolting and/or pornographic photos.
    • Handle photos of the suicide victim or the suicide scene with care, and pixelate or blur the picture when appropriate.
    • Do not use made-up conversation or plots to describe the suicide process, consequences of or reason for the suicide.
    • Avoid using computer graphics or animation to describe the process, consequences of or reason for the suicide.
    • Avoid enlarging photos of suicides or suicide attempts, such as photos depicting a person jumping off a building.

    Appreciation of Privacy

    • Respect the victim’s family privacy to avoid adding to their pain and sorrow.
    • Consideration should be given to the victim’s friends and family. Avoid the over reporting of a suicide incident, as it might affect their emotional recovery.

    Education and Prevention

    • Consider including the signs of suicidal behavior in news reports to alertpeople who could offer help to people at risk of suicide.
    • Provide solutions and ways to seek help whenever possible in news reports,such as through comments and opinions from psychologists, social workers and teachers.
    • Provide information on and contact details for mental health and counseling services in news report to assist and support at risk people and their families.

    It’s hard to believe that Apple Daily would sign up for this, but surely the South China Morning Post could do so.

  • It’s very kind of them to make Spotify available in Hong Kong, but their stupid software doesn’t work.  I am running Windows 7 (64 bit) and the Spotify application works for anything from 30 seconds to a few minutes before crashing – and it’s impossible to close it and restart it.

    The Android app works, but is hardly usable because it drains the battery within a few hours.

    Which just leaves the web version, but that only seems to work in Chrome – and requires Flash Player, which I had disabled.

    Well, at least Google and Apple aren’t competing with them.  Oh, hang on, yes they are.

  • It has been apparent for at least 10 years that the government had no wish to continue subsidizing the ESF.  The real surprise is that it has taken so long to make this decision – and it will only start to take effect three years from now, with some subsidy remaining in place for another 13 years (until the last pupils admitted to ESF primary schools in August 2015 complete their studies).

    The SCMP has two news stories and one opinion piece:

    Decision to end ESF subsidy a lesson in Machiavellian ruthlessness

    South China Morning Post | Saturday, 08 June, 2013 | Alex Lo

    Shock and horror! Fees for schools under the English Schools Foundation from 2016 will be at least 23 per cent higher as the government phases out the public subsidy.

    But you would expect that. The die was cast once the Education Bureau announced it would phase out the current subsidy. You want to know how much ESF parents will eventually have to pay? Just check out the fees of other international schools.

    The decision to end the subsidy after freezing payment for a decade may go down in history as one of the most ruthless made by this administration. But before you pick up your pitchfork and bay for blood, it's not entirely the fault of Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying and his education secretary, Eddie Ng Hak-kim. Of course it is their fault for allowing it to happen. But I am actually not sure they know what they are doing with the ESF in the sense they almost certainly did not come up with the policy decision – those immediately below Ng within the bureau did.

    There is an almost Machiavellian elegance to the decision – if you discount its irresponsibility, unfairness and immorality. You can be sure our clueless Mr Ng would never come up with something so clever; this is reserved for the senior administrative officials within the bureau, not a few of whom – I bet – are, or were, ESF parents.

    Let's see what this decision really means. Taxpayers' money will be saved. The ESF is certain to prosper, as it will be able to charge high fees and million-dollar debentures on a par with other international schools. The government can claim it is helping to boost international school places without lifting a finger. It is also a populist decision as many local families resent the real or perceived special treatment given to the ESF as an old colonial institution.

    But it is never explained why it is no longer the government's responsibility to support affordable education for non-Chinese-speaking children of residents or permanent residents. Nor is it clear why local families should be left to their own devices once they leave the local system and join the international school sector.

    But the reality is that these families are on their own unless they can pay the high school fees.

    The government’s official reason for ending the subvention is that it "flies in the face of the government's policy of not providing recurrent subsidy to schools mainly running non-local curriculum."

    It’s the word “mainly” that appears to be the crucial one.  Schools operating under the Direct Subsidy Scheme (DSS) are allowed to have 49% of their students in an “international” stream that leads to qualifications such as IGCSE and IB Diploma, but must have 51% studying for local exams.

    It would be a huge change to the ESF to be able to satisfy the DSS rules, and so the ESF Board has accepted the government decision but they have arranged meetings with parents to get their views.  Expect these meetings to be lively, and ESF management will be heavily criticized, but current parents are not the ones who will lose the most from this decision, and it’s not possible to consult with parents of future ESF students.

    On Friday, the HK Standard quoted Secretary for Education Eddie Ng Hak-kim on the lack of international school places, saying that “international schools [should] consider devising an allocation mechanism such as a certain proportion of places being earmarked for children whose parents are recruited or relocated from outside Hong Kong."  So it seems clear the government wants the ESF to operate as an international school, offering priority to expats - and there is no doubt that the ESF can be successful operating in that way.

    The losers here are local parents who can’t afford higher school fees, but the government doesn’t care about them.

  • Interesting piece from Gweipo about newspapers:

    Buy a newspaper – save a journalist?

    I've been subjected to a barrage of emails of late by the IHT.  And the Wall street journal.  And the NYT. [..] Why did I resist?  A few main reasons.  I just hate all that paper coming into the house – even if I'm now living in an area that professes to recycle and even will reward me for doing so through their "Grin" Scheme. (Honest, they don't have to, my guilt to the environment is enough to keep me recycling forever and forever amen).  Then there is that thing of other waste – as in, I subscribe, but some weeks I'll read the paper every day, and sometimes weeks on end go by with the paper piling up, in it's little plastic bag against the rain (double guilt, double waste) unopened until I separate the paper and the plastic and throw them all out.  And finally the fact that it's available online and on air.  Oh, and they don't have suduko (the saving grace of the SCMP – honest, ask any expat wife, they all start with that section).  And their comics are pathetic – old fashioned, boring and irrelevant to an international audience. 

    You see, the best thing about my IHT subscription to be honest, was unlimited access to the NYT.  And, in the days that I didn't get to read the newspaper, I could skim through my daily email from the NYT and click on the articles that were interesting.  Now, I can still do that.  I'm limited to 10 articles a month – but, often that's enough.  And it's a kind of rationing – do I really like that journalist enough to click through or is it going to be a same old same old?

    The article generated a response from Joyce Hor-Chung Lau, an editor at the International Herald Tribune (writing in a personal capacity):

    I do pay for online content — I feel responsible to do so. One pet peeve are people (not you) who say, "I love your paper, but I get annoyed when I get blocked after 10 articles." I want to shake them and ask why they expect content to come for free? And these are not poor people — mostly HK professionals. One was my dentist. It was hard for me to retort, w/ the metal instruments in my mouth. But I wanted to ask him if he had qualms about asking me to pay for my dental care!

    It would be nice if the media industry made it easier to buy a la carte articles. Often, I see one article I'd like to read — and would be happy to pay a few bucks if I could click one PayPal button. But then I'm asked to buy a whole year's subscription or have to fill in some form, and I give up.

    Yes, the ‘micro payments’ model ought to work, but how much would people pay per article?  Would it be worth collecting the money?   

    It’s interesting that the SCMP has stuck with charging for its website for so many years, whilst other papers have either stayed free or have tried different approaches to charging, usually without much success.  SCMP.com now allows access to a certain number of articles free of charge (the same as the New York Times and the Financial Times, but unlike The Times) and the website is much better than before.  Unfortunately the content (of the newspaper and website) is getting worse – and reduced revenue must be one reason.

    People may be reluctant to pay for web access, but apparently they will pay for content on iPad and Kindle.  I do.  I happily pay about US$0.60 per day for The Guardian on the Kindle, but I hated their iPad app.  The Kindle experience is less than ideal for magazines, but at little more than US$1 per week (each) for The Spectator and the New Statesman I’m not complaining.  The question is whether this will be enough to save newspapers and magazines.

  • I think I may have noticed a theme to these “Dean Fung English” articles" in the Hong Kong Standard:

    Tatto artist jailed for sex with girl, 11

  • They had another one of those International Cheese Festivals at Hullett House in TST.

    The problem is that the cheese market is in a tiny room.  I had to wait in a queue before I was allowed in, but there were still too many people inside.  I did manage to try the only Scottish cheese they had (from Barwheys Dairy), and so I bought some of that, and a couple of French cheeses before I gave up.  Not cheap at HK$55 per 100g, but I’d have bought more if it had been better organized.

    From there I went to the Shangri-La, which had this rather puzzling dish in its buffet:

    image

    Yes, that’s shepherds pie.

  • I’m obviously not paying attention, so I only found out from Spike that Spotify is now available in Hong Kong.

    There’s the usual pantomime with a default page that is only in Chinese, and no obvious way to change to English.  Google Chrome makes it easier by translating it (rather badly), otherwise you would be left with having to know the Chinese characters for English.  No, me neither. 

    The good news?  It’s only HK$48 per month (compared with $9.99 in the US and £9.99 in the UK).

  • Why is the SCMP still printing these tedious letters from Pierce Lam?  As well as attacking the ESF (yawn) he is now trying to defend the “designated schools” scheme: 

    Why officials should end ESF subsidy

    South China Morning Post | 2 April 2013

    Simon Osborn rightly recognises that the English Schools Foundation’s "old policy" discriminates against native Cantonese-speaking children but wrongly claims its new policy will offer equal opportunity ("ESF’s new policy offers equal chance", March 25).

    As the new policy gives priority to siblings and children of alumni, it perpetuates non-Chinese speakers’ preferential admission.

    Non-Chinese children of non-permanent residents now account for 30 per cent of the ESF’s student population, but constitute less than 2 per cent of the city’s population.

    According to ESF CEO Heather Du Quesnay, the new system would not "reduce the number of non-Chinese students at ESF schools" ("ESF ends priority for non-Chinese speakers", February 5). The ESF’s selling of nomination rights and questionable test on "parental commitment" won’t moderate the warped effects of its old policy.

    Betty Bownath is right about the importance of non-Cantonese speakers’ "integration into mainstream public schools" and "full immersion with extension or support classes for Chinese being the fairest and best option for ethnic minorities" ("Segregation still confronts ethnic students", March 22). But she misunderstands The New York Times article of March 10 and wrongly criticises Hong Kong’s "designated schools".

    Under Hong Kong’s 12-year compulsory education, every school-aged child is guaranteed a school place. But, as the city is demographically 96 per cent Cantonese-speaking, the average public school isn’t well prepared for the special needs of non-Cantonese speakers. Designated schools are mainstream schools which have joined a government scheme whereby they receive additional funding for the purpose of implementing school-based measures to help non Cantonese-speaking students.

    Ms Bownath has overlooked the encouraging experience of Talwinder Singh, a designated school student who features in The New York Times article. He said he was glad to be in a designated school and would feel alone in a mainstream school. He said his teachers knew how to deal with minority students. He is thinking of universities after graduation this summer from a "designated school" where he studies alongside the school’s Cantonese-speaking students.

    The government should cut the ESF’s subsidy because of that institution’s practice of segregation based on linguistic discrimination, and divert such funding to help more mainstream schools develop the capability of designated schools and serve all ethnic minorities, native English speakers included, equally.

    Pierce Lam, Central

    The problem with Pierce Lam is that he decided a long time ago that the ESF was a dastardly plot by the evil colonial administration and nothing could possibly convince him to change his mind.  So, even when they abolish the priority for non-Cantonese speakers (that he has been complaining about for years) he argues that nothing has changed. 

    On the other hand, when the government claim that their “designated schools” scheme is a serious attempt to cater for non-Cantonese speakers, he is convinced that this must be true.  Because of course, the Hong Kong government can be trusted, unlike the wicked witch Heather Du Quesnay and the rest of them over at the ESF.

    Here’s another article which comes to a similar conclusion as the one in the New York Times:

    Racism in the classroom?

    Time Out Hong Kong |  25 Oct 2011

    Li Sing Tai Hang School in Causeway Bay, is one of 28 designated schools in Hong Kong that receive additional funds and resources from the government to help minority students. During the central allocation process, where the Education Bureau divvies up pupils according to the ‘school nets’ they are located in, most minority students end up being assigned to a designated school even if it isn’t located within their net. According to the Education Bureau, at present, among some 12,000 non-Chinese speaking students, about 60 percent are studying in designated schools.

    “It’s racial segregation,” says Fermi Wong Wai-fun, executive director of Hong Kong Unison, a non-governmental organisation focusing on helping minority groups. Wong says up to 80 percent of minority students attend designated schools – but, she claims, some Hong Kong parents become unwilling to choose these schools for their children. “They [minority students] have been living and studying in a very narrow social circle and have become disconnected with the mainstream society. It will harm social integration,” says Wong.

    But I have probably “misunderstood” this article, just like Betty Bownath did with the one in the New York Times, and really it is a fantastic scheme.

  • Does anyone really know the difference between Satsumas, Clementines, Tangerines and Mandarins?

    20130321_144424Or the Mikan, sometimes imported from Japan or Korea?  Yes please, but they are more expensive.

    20130321_144433Honey Murcott anyone?  No thanks, or at least not the ones from Bangladesh in Park’n’Shop.

    For the last couple of years, Park’n’Shop have been importing Spanish satsumas, but this year they have been disappointing – dried up.

    Just recently they have started importing Sunkist Satsumas and Mandarins from the USA.  No, I don’t think I can tell the difference, even though they are carefully labelled up as different products

    Here are some of the fruit on display in my local Park’n’Shop

    20130316_203151

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    And here’s a lovely fresh apple:

    20130205_104039

  • I wrote about the Championship merry-go-round shortly after Michael Appleton had become Blackburn’s third manager of the season in mid-January.  Now’s he’s become the 32nd manager to be fired this season.  Where would Blackburn be without Venky’s  and their global football adviser, Shebby Singh?  Don’t answer that.

    It was only a few weeks ago that Appleton was quoted as saying that “if Shebby Singh is global advising, he’s not advising me”.  Now it seems that Singh has had the last laugh by getting rid of him.

    Alex McLeish?  He lasted just 39 days as Nottingham Forest before leaving by “mutual consent” (which for once seemed not to be just a polite way of saying that he had been fired).  He left shortly after the peculiar business with George Boyd “failing a medical” on deadline day. 

    Anyone else?  Ah yes, Simon Grayson was sacked by Huddersfield Town after a run of twelve matches without a win, though his successor has not been notably more successful.

    And in the Premier League, Reading demonstrated that they could be every bit as ungrateful to a manager who had got them promoted as Southampton had been a few weeks earlier, by firing Brian McDermott.     

    It’s all madness, I tell you.

    Wolves remain in turmoil and face second successive relegation

    Some decisions have been unfathomable. Sacking Mick McCarthy last February and replacing him with his assistant, Terry Connor, was madness. The appointment of Stale Solbakken in the summer was another error of judgment. Unveiled in May as the man to take Wolves back to the Premier League with a more refined style of play, Solbakken was sacked eight months later following a humiliating FA Cup defeat at non-league Luton Town. By that point, the players had long become exasperated with the Norwegian’s methods.

    Eager to get rid of "the Mick McCarthy culture", Solbakken felt the best way forward was to empower the players. Standards dropped, discipline disappeared – Bakary Sako went unpunished after reporting late for one game – and training lost its competitive edge, with some of the drills regarded as ridiculously basic. Johan Lange and Patrick Weiser, the assistant manager and first-team coach Solbakken brought in to work alongside him, had little authority.

    When things started to go badly wrong on the pitch, Solbakken was reluctant to read the riot act, prompting Roger Johnson, whose own time at Wolves has been little short of a disaster, to confront the manager in the changing room during the run of three straight league defeats before the Luton game. Johnson, along with a few other players, felt that Solbakken needed to adopt a tougher line and urged him to point the finger. Solbakken, keen to avoid confrontation, refused.

    If Solbakken’s departure was inevitable, Saunders’s arrival represented a surprise, in part because of the speed with which things happened but also because he was the only person interviewed. Sean O’Driscoll, who had been harshly dismissed by Nottingham Forest, was available, yet he never got a look in. O’Driscoll went on to take over at Bristol City, where he has picked up 17 points from his 11 games in charge. Saunders has eight points from the same number of matches.

    Though, to be fair to Wolves and Dean Saunders, they did win last Saturday.